Monday, February 22, 2016
Pope Francis, Donald Trump, and Walls and Bridges
By Allan Wall
Pope Francis has just made his first official papal visit to Mexico.
is the first pontiff from the Jesuit order, and was born Jorge Mario Bergoglio, in Argentina, to an Italian-immigrant father
and a mother whose family is of Italian origin.
Pope Francis continues the
tradition of recent popes to make papal visits to various countries.
The previous pontiff, Pope Benedict XVI (2005-2013) visited Mexico in 2012.
The pope before Benedict was John Paul II (1978-2005), who traveled so much that he was seen in person by more human
beings than anybody else in history. John Paul II visited Mexico five times, and seems to have had a special
bond with the Mexican people.
Nevertheless, despite all the hoopla over papal visits,
the Mexican Catholic church is in decline. It’s declining as a proportion of the population, it’s
declining in its influence, and it can’t recruit enough Mexican priests.
about four out of five Mexicans claim to be Catholic – but it’s been estimated that only about a quarter of Mexicans
are serious practicing Catholics.
Still, it’s impossible
to understand Mexican history and traditional Mexican culture without understanding Catholicism, and even nominal Catholicism
still has a lot of cultural power. A pope can still draw the multitudes in Mexico.
Pope Francis visited Mexico from February 12th to 18th, and spent time in Mexico City, Morelia, Chiapas and Chihuahua,
thus traveling from one end of the country to the other.
On his last full day in Mexico,
the pontiff celebrated a mass on the Mexican side of the U.S.-Mexican border, where he decried the humanitarian crisis on
After departing Mexico, the Pope was interviewed on the
plane and was asked about Donald Trump’s candidacy in the United States. In reply, Pope Francis had
this to say: "A person who thinks only about building walls, wherever they may be, and not building bridges, is not Christian.
This is not the gospel.”
Whether we look at this statement from a Christian or
political perspective, it’s rather problematic.
In the first place, I’m
not aware of the Pope speaking in this way of any other public figure. Who else has he called “not
The Pope’s “walls and bridges” statement is not
derived from the Bible or Catholic catechism. It’s a lightweight and incoherent slogan.
Surely the Pope must be aware of the distinction Jesus Christ set forth between human and divine government, expressed
in the reply to the question about tribute paid to Caesar. (See Matthew 22:15-22.)
Civil governments have the responsibility to protect the
inhabitants of their earthly nation-states. Such functions include enforcing criminal law, maintaining
military forces, and protecting borders.
As for walls and bridges, both are useful and both have
their proper functions.
The purpose of the church is not to carry out the responsibilities
of earthly governments. The purpose of the church is to advance the Kingdom of God.
Why doesn’t Pope Francis put more pressure on Latin American clergy to take care of poor Latin Americans in their
own countries? That would be better than encouraging Mexicans and Central Americans to travel illegally
to the United States.
U.S. immigration policy is a constant target in Latin
America. However, consider this. The U.S. has half the population of Latin America (and
less land). Nevertheless, the U.S. has taken in six times the number of immigrants as all of Latin America
(and 24 times the amount as the Pope’s native Argentina). Yet they still complain.
Furthermore, how can the Pope rail against walls when the Vatican itself is surrounded by walls? The
Vatican doesn’t have an open borders policy, does it? The Vatican is protected by armed guards,
as is the Pope himself when he travels.
In an excellent
piece published by The American Thinker, Silvio Canto, Jr. points out that on his visit to Cuba, Pope Francis “…
hugged and embraced Raúl Castro, a man who has executed priests, harassed religious leaders, and closed Christian schools
years ago. Did he call the Castro brothers un-Christian?” (Click here for Silvio’s article.)
The day after the Pope’s comments, Vatican
spokesman Federico Lombardi said in an interview that the Pope was not attacking candidate Trump and was not telling people
how to vote.
I doubt this is the last time we can expect to hear from the Vatican
(a walled city-state) on this topic.
Allan Wall, an educator, resided in Mexico for many years. His website is located at http://www.allanwall.info